Q IF MY husband and I have made a mutual will and either of us dies, is the will still valid or must the surviving party make a fresh will?
If he makes a new will by himself after the mutual will is made, will it make the mutual will invalid?
I have nominated my three children and husband as the beneficiaries of my insurance policy. What will happen if one of my beneficiaries dies?
If I have left my other assets, other than insurance and Central Provident Fund savings, to my children and husband, what will happen if one of them dies after my death?
Is there a difference in writing a will for different insurance policies?
A THE term ‘mutual wills’ is generally used to describe joint or separate wills made as a result of an agreement between, for instance, husband and wife, to create an irrevocable interest for certain beneficiaries.
For example, husband H makes a will bequeathing his property to wife W and after her death to child C.
At the same time, wife W makes a will bequeathing her property to husband H and after his death to child C.
Mutual wills are not simply wills that have been executed in identical terms.
They must indicate an agreement between the parties that each party has executed his or her own will in certain terms because the other party is similarly executing a will in certain terms.
These mutual wills are akin to a contract made between the parties. It is advisable that the terms of this ‘agreement’ be expressly stated in the respective mutual wills. More often than not, mutual wills would also expressly state that both parties agree not to revoke their wills and/or alter the terms of distribution in the mutual wills.
In relation to your first question, once the two mutual wills are made, and one of the parties dies, there is no need for the surviving party to make a fresh will as the mutual will is still in effect and valid.
As regards your second question, strictly speaking when a person makes a new will, he would normally revoke all previous wills made by him and the latest will would be the one that is valid and which takes effect.
In certain situations, the court may still give effect to the terms of the original mutual will.
Although your husband’s latest will would be proved in court, the court, if asked, may still give effect to the terms of the original mutual will and order that your husband’s estate be distributed to the beneficiaries stated in the original mutual will.
This is notwithstanding that your husband has revoked the original mutual will by executing a new will.
Using the example in the first paragraph above, if after your death, husband H makes a new will bequeathing his property to a third party T, the court may order that T hold H’s estate on trust for child C.
If this kind of situation arises, litigation and a consequent court ruling are likely to be necessary.
The factors that the court would take into account include whether your husband made his new will before or after your death, and whether you were aware of his new will and, if so, your reasons for not altering or revoking your mutual will. A key consideration would also be which party died first.
The court would also need to consider whether the terms of the will as well as the surrounding circumstances could show that you and your husband had made an agreement to execute a mutual will, and that both of you had agreed not to revoke the mutual wills and/or alter the beneficiaries.
The mere fact that the mutual wills were made in identical terms is insufficient. Each case would ultimately depend on its own facts.
On your third question, if one of your intended beneficiaries of the proceeds of your insurance policies dies before you do, you should take steps to inform the institution where the insurance was purchased and amend your nominated beneficiaries accordingly.
You will need to liaise with your insurance agent about this, and whether or not this can be done is ultimately dependent on the terms of your policy.
In answer to your fourth question, please note that generally, unless your will provides otherwise, the bequests made by you in your will, to a beneficiary who subsequently dies after your death, would be given to the estate of such deceased beneficiary and distributed in accordance to the terms of such deceased beneficiary’s will or the law of intestate succession, as the case may be.
On your fifth question, you should note that, generally speaking, if you have named specific beneficiaries for your insurance policies, upon your death, under the law, the proceeds payable on such policies will not be distributed in accordance with your will. Instead, such proceeds will be distributed to the beneficiaries named in your policy.
If there are no specific beneficiaries named for your policies or if the beneficiary of the policy is stated to be ‘the estate’, such proceeds would be distributed in accordance with your will.
In the latter case, you may wish to specify in your will, the manner in which you would like the proceeds of each insurance policy to be distributed.
Navin Joseph LoboLegal associateHarry Elias Partnership
Q RECENTLY, my brother and I obtained Singapore citizenship. My parents are Malaysians.
If they want to draft a will to leave us their assets, should it be done in Singapore or Malaysia? If they do not have a will, how will their assets be distributed? Is it according to the Intestate Act of Malaysia or Singapore?
A IF YOUR parents own immovable property, such as land, in Malaysia, Malaysian law will govern the distribution of an intestate estate - that is, where no will was left.
For Malaysian-registered cars and shares listed on the Malaysian stock exchange, Malaysian law also applies.
If a person dies intestate while ordinarily resident in Malaysia, I would assume that Malaysian law will govern the distribution of the estate under the Malaysian intestacy laws.
If your parents have immovable property in Singapore, this part of their property will be governed by Singapore law.
If they ordinarily reside in Malaysia and are likely to stay there until the end of their lives, it makes sense to have a will drafted in Malaysia.
Technically, it makes no difference which country the will is drafted in, as long as it is validly drafted and signed/witnessed, as it is sufficient to inform of your parents’ wishes with regard to their estate.
If they die in Malaysia and are domiciled, that is, usually living, in Malaysia, the Intestate Succession Act of the country will apply.
The Intestate Succession Act of Singapore applies only to one who dies intestate either domiciled in Singapore and having any property - such as land, cash and shares - in Singapore, or one who dies intestate domiciled out of Singapore but having immovable property in Singapore.Lim Choi MingLawyerTM Hoon & CompanyAdvice provided in this column is not meant as a substitute for comprehensive professional advice.
Source : Sunday Times - 1 Jan 2006