Despite big chunk of payment going towards interest costs, experts warn against repaying home loans too quickly
MR GILBERT Goh Keow Wah recently sold his condominium unit when he got tired of paying nearly $2,000 a month for his mortgage.
The bulk - 85 per cent - of that went to paying the interest, he said.
‘Most people would be shocked to know that of our repayment, only about $300 was principal repayment while close to $1,700 was interest servicing. Our loan amount hardly moved,’ he wrote in the Inbox column of this newspaper last Sunday.
His letter sparked scores of postings on several Internet finance forums. Some writers said they did not realise so much of a repayment could go to cover the interest cost.
A writer at www.sgfunds.com suggested that everyone should clear his home loan in 10 years or less. Among his ideas for achieving this is to repay some of the capital every few months, when one has spare cash or Central Provident Fund (CPF) savings.
But some financial experts The Sunday Times spoke to disagreed with a ‘pay up as fast as you can’ approach. In the first place, Mr Goh’s experience of having his interest cost amounting to 85 per cent of his mortgage repayment is rare.
Figures of about 60 per cent and below for the initial period of a loan are more common - according to a Sunday Times calculation and checks with mortgage experts.
That is based on the following loan assumptions:
Loan of $300,000 repayable over 30 years; and
An interest rate of 3 per cent a year in the first three years and 3.75 per cent in subsequent years.
Those interest rates reflect market rates as they are roughly the average of rates charged by some packages available at DBS Bank and United Overseas Bank (UOB).
One thing to note is that typically, the interest portion of a mortgage repayment is highest in the initial years, declining to practically nothing at the end of the repayment period, says Mr Bryan Ong, a senior associate manager at real estate firm PropNex. So even if 85 per cent went to paying the interest on Mr Goh’s mortgage, this percentage would tumble over time.
Anyone keen on reducing his interest payment could opt for a shorter loan tenure. If the tenure were 15 years for the mortgage package cited above, the interest portion would be 35 per cent in the first year and would decline from then onwards.
Aside from a long loan tenure, another cause of high interest components is simply the interest rate charged on the mortgage.
In his letter, Mr Goh did not say what rate he was charged but when contacted, he said it was 6.25 per cent a year. He could have refinanced to obtain a lower rate.
But Mr Goh, who has switched to a Housing Board (HDB) maisonette, said he could not get a new loan as he has been delinquent in paying up when he was unemployed during the 2001 recession.
In any case, he is happier now. ‘My wife and I are fortunate to be free of loans for this new purchase, given the amount of CPF savings we have accumulated over the years.’
Mr Goh, 45, now works as a career consultant with a statutory board. For his previous loan of about $350,000, he had estimated he would be paying close to 100 per cent of that amount in interest alone after 25 years.
Again, his case is rare and is based on a very high interest rate.
The total interest paid comprises 39 per cent based on the mortgage scenario cited earlier involving a loan of $300,000 repaid over 30 years. If the same loan package is shortened to 15 years, the total interest paid is only 22 per cent of the total repayment.
Pay up slowly?
SO MUCH for the numbers. When it comes to the idea of paying off a mortgage as soon as possible, some experts think it is not necessarily the best route for everyone.
Mr Ong, the property manager, says he would rather invest his surplus money in stocks and unit trusts as the stock market is booming.
The Straits Times Index reached record highs this month. Similarly, other regional stock markets have been climbing strongly.
You would have made investment gains far exceeding the 2.6 per cent a year interest cost of an HDB loan.
Stock markets are volatile and if you are risk-averse, it can still make sense to invest your money in fixed deposits and Singapore Government bonds paying more than 3 per cent a year, notes Associate Professor Benedict Koh of the Singapore Management University.
The choice gets tougher if your loan comes from a bank that charges, say, 5 per cent a year in interest.
Not everyone is savvy enough about investing. ‘And investments don’t always behave the way we would love them to,’ says Ms Rosie Tang, a certified financial planner.
‘Think about it, by paying up the loan, you are effectively making a ‘no risk’ return of 5 per cent a year!’
If you would rather scale down your mortgage debt and steer clear of the stock market, she says: ‘Don’t rush off to redeem your loan. Review your overall finances, other needs and investments carefully and consult a financial adviser.’
Russell Investment Group director Lim Meng Tat says you should pay off your mortgage early but not at the expense of having little money left for long-term investments. To that end, people should not take up an overly huge housing loan, he adds.
Mr Dennis Ng, 37, a certified financial planner, says he could afford to pay off his mortgage right away but wants to stretch it till he is 51.
‘Have you seen people who have cashflow problems and regretted paying off or reducing their mortgage? I’ve seen many. They ask if I can help them apply for a loan on their house again to tide over their cashflow problems. I have to tell them ‘no’.’
With the establishment of the Credit Bureau in 2002, people who have defaulted on their loans have had little or no chance of getting a loan, he says. Worst off are those who have paid off their HDB mortgages, or even partially paid off the mortgages.
HDB rules do not allow such home owners to apply again for mortgages on the same homes from banks or the HDB, says Mr Ng.
He adds that people would not be making a rational decision if they pay off their home loans but take up a car loan that charges rates of about 6 per cent, the current market rate.
What if you want the best of liquid cash and reduced interest cost on your mortgage? Consider mortgages that will pay you the same interest rate on your cash as the interest rate that is charged on your mortgage.
Citibank, HSBC, Standard Chartered and UOB offer such schemes.
The bottom line is that Citibank’s customers enjoy an average of 10 per cent savings on their interest payments, says Mr Tan Chia Seng, its business director for secured assets group. With the savings, they can pay off their loans faster, he says.
Source : Sunday Times - 29 Oct 2006