Couple loses appeal to block Waterfront View sale
The couple opposing the collective sale of the Bedok condominium Waterfront View yesterday lost their appeal in the High Court.
Mr Yeo Loo Keng and his wife Cheryl Lim, the only owners in the 583-unit former HUDC estate still holding out against the sale, had argued that they stood to make a loss of about $90,000 in their Central Provident Fund accounts if the sale went through.
This argument was rejected by the Strata Titles Board (STB) in February, in a landmark ruling. It was the first time the STB had to decide if CPF money can be considered a financial loss in the sale of homes.
High Court judge Belinda Ang yesterday upheld that decision, noting that Mr Yeo, a 43-year-old businessman, and Madam Lim, 40, would still be able to redeem their existing mortgage with the money from the collective sale.
The shortfall in their CPF accounts cannot be considered a deductible expense.
The couple, who bought their 14th-floor, 1,711 sq ft apartment about 12 years ago for $515,000, stand to be paid about $660,000 from the sale.
But they say they will make a loss of $88,340.37 - a part of their CPF principal amounts and the interest accrued to their CPF accounts - after redeeming their outstanding mortgage.
The CPF Board has said they need not make good on that shortfall.
Waterfront View’s sales committee member Kevin Tan said the High Court ruling made it clear what can or cannot be accounted for in a collective sale.
‘You prevent a situation where you end up compensating someone because you don’t know what the situation is,’ he said.
Dr Tan estimated that about 300 Waterfront View owners had already bought new homes, while at least 150 have moved out of the estate.
Waterfront View was sold for $385 million last May to FCL Peak, a joint venture between Frasers Centrepoint and Far East Organization.
A disappointed Mr Yeo told The Straits Times yesterday that he was now going to start looking for a new home.
‘Who is to say that the next place that we buy may not be sold en bloc and we may be hit again? I would have to think hard about buying another place in Singapore,’ he said.
Source : Straits Times - 28 Apr 2007
Loading ...
Post a Comment
Tell me a bit about yourself; who you are, where you're from, what information you would like to see on this site. As I continue to provide you with Singapore property happenings, your feedback will encourage me to post more frequently. Thank you.