They buy one for $135,000
They do so under HDB’s Joint Singles Scheme
One wants to sell, the other doesn’t
They were colleagues in 1998, both bachelors and past 35 years old.
Neither had a place of his own. So they decided to buy an HDB flat together under the Joint Singles Scheme.
They thought they could make a profit too after five years, when HDB rules would allow them to sell it.
Now, nine years after they bought the flat, what they have instead is one big mess.
Mr Chin Kim Fatt, now 49, said he has been waiting for three years for the flat to be sold so that he can buy a new flat and marry his 41-year-old girlfriend.
And Mr Teo G H, 45, who is already married and was evicted from the flat last year, said he and his family have nowhere to live.
The three-room flat in Ang Mo Kio, which cost the men $141,000, is finally in the process of being sold. But Mr Chin, now a foot reflexologist, regrets having bought it at all.
Things began to go wrong from the beginning. Both men were retrenched and found it difficult to repay the loan they had taken from HDB.
They couldn’t live together either and after just three months, Mr Chin moved out.
BROTHER MOVED IN
He claimed he had to sleep in the living room after Mr Teo’s brother joined them in the flat. Mr Teo would bring his girlfriend to the flat, and after they got married in 1999, she moved in too. They have two children.
Mr Chin, who has lived in rented rooms since leaving the flat, claimed he tried to move back in 2001 but was told there was no room for him. Mr Teo claimed Mr Chin had left without even telling him.
Things continued in this way till 2003, when the five-year minimum occupation period was up. They could then sell the flat, but Mr Teo refused to.
Mr Chin had a Malaysian girlfriend by then, and she had agreed to marry him.
His girlfriend is a divorcee with a 13-year-old son. They live with her parents in Malacca. He visits them once a month for four days each time.
He wanted to sell the flat as quickly as possible because, according to the rules, he would have to wait another 30 months before he would be eligible to buy or rent from HDB again.
And he said he couldn’t afford a flat on the open market. Nor did he want to ask his bride to join him in a rented room.
Mr Chin said: ‘I’ve had to spend $400 to $500 of my $1,300 monthly salary on rent all these years. Meanwhile, Mr Teo and his family had been living in the flat all this while.’
Finally, in 2004, Mr Chin hired a lawyer to take legal action. On 28 Jan 2005, Mr Teo’s lawyer informed the court that he had no objection to selling the flat.
REPOSSESS
Later that year, when no action had been taken to sell the flat, Mr Chin obtained a court order telling Mr Teo to vacate the flat by 15 May 2006.
The date came and went, and Mr Teo’s family stayed put.
They too had a problem with the 30-month rule and sought an exemption. And they claimed they had nowhere to move to.
Mr Teo’s wife said: ‘We didn’t mind selling the flat as we can’t pay the loan instalments. But if we sold it, where would we go?’
HDB has been helping Mr Teo out under its deferment of loan instalments and reduced repayment schemes.
Finally, Mr Chin got a court order to repossess the flat.
On 15 Aug last year, Mr Teo’s family was evicted and their property removed from the flat by a contractor Mr Chin had engaged.
Mr Chin said: ‘I’ve given him (Mr Teo) many chances. Even after getting the court order to evict him and his family, I gave them two weeks to move out before I went to the flat with the bailiff.’
It was not easy to sell the flat because it had been vandalised by loan sharks since 2003. Both men claim the loan sharks were after the other.
But now a buyer has been found and the deal is expected to be completed soon.
The sale price is $140,000, but the men still owe HDB $13,000 and, after returning to their CPF accounts what they had taken out to buy the flat, they may not have much left.
Mr Teo and his family are staying with his parents and two brothers for now.
When the sale is completed, he and his wife will be applying for a two-room rental flat from HDB.
Mrs Teo said: ‘HDB exempted us from the 30-month wait, but we can apply for the rental flat only when the flat is sold.
‘We want a place near the children’s school, which is in Hougang. But when I checked recently, only flats in Marine Parade and Woodlands were available.’
As for Mr Chin, he still doesn’t know when he’ll be able to get married.
He wants to buy or rent a two-room flat from HDB.
He too has approached HDB for an exemption from the 30-month wait, but is unsure of the outcome.
He said: ‘After this flat matter is settled, I’ll have to ask my girlfriend to marry me again.
‘I don’t know if she’ll still want to.’
From flat- mates to foes
1998
Mr Chin and Mr Teo, both single and older than 35 years, buy 3-room flat for $141,000 under the Joint Singles Scheme.
1999
Mr Chin moves out. Mr Teo stays on and gets married.
2003
Mr Chin wants to sell the flat but Mr Teo refuses. Mr Chin and his fiancee cannot apply for a new flat together.
2004
Mr Chin takes legal action.
2005
Court orders Mr Teo to vacate the flat.
2006
Mr Teo is evicted from the flat.
2007
The flat is being sold for $140,000. But Mr Chin may have to wait 30 months after the sale is completed before he can rent or buy a flat from HDB directly.
Choose your co-owner carefully
Think carefully before you buy a flat with another single person.
An HDB spokesman said singles aged 35 and above can buy resale flats on their own under the Single Singapore Citizen Scheme.
So it is not necessary for them to pair up to buy resale flats under the Joint Singles Scheme. Last year, only 214 of the 5,300 resale applications by singles were under this scheme.
HDB does not keep tabs on the number of joint flat owner who cannot get along. ‘We believe that they are a small minority,’ said the spokesman. ‘Those who pair up to jointly purchase a flat… should have been aware that home ownership is a long-term commitment, and should have considered carefully the choice of their joint owner before they made the purchase.’
Madam Ho Geok Choo, MP for West Coast GRC, said she has come across a few of these disputes in her constituency.
They are mostly issues arising from differing lifestyles and habits.
She suggested that HDB could present to singles who want to buy a flat jointly different scenarios that could arise later on.
Source : New Paper - 6 Jun 2007