SGHOUSING.COM 新加坡房地产网

IN HIS letter, ‘Sense of kampung in condos overstated’ (March 20), Mr Lau Chee Kian warned that ‘old estates’ could ‘degenerate into slums like in many countries’. Nassim Park was only 14 years old when it went en bloc although it was in very good condition.

Horizon Hill Towers, the subject of the long running and costly acrimonious dispute now being heard in the High Court, is in pristine condition even though it is older than Nassim Park. Cavenagh Gardens in Cavenagh Road was built in the early 1960s whereas Pacific Mansion in the River Valley area and built slightly later are now around 45 years old and can hardly be considered slums by any standard, being in much better condition than some of the HDB flats only about 20 years old.

Whether an estate would turn into a slum is more dependent on the maintenance rather than age, as the many examples in China, India, Europe and others where some of the buildings are centuries old, have shown. ‘The fact that the majority are willing to sell’ needs not and does not justify the compulsory sale by dissenting subsidiary proprietors, as the former’s decision could have been misconceived, ill advised, wrongly influenced, etc, and, as it is, turned out to be wrong, because in most cases the price they sold was too low. Dispute, acrimony and ruined lives could have been avoided from the beginning if all those concerned had faced up to the root causes and inherent deficiencies faced in most management corporations.

Bin Hee Heng

Source : Straits Times - 29 Mar 2008